Casey Kaplan
Jordan Casteel Is Making You Look
FEBRUARY 27, 2018
By JULIA FELSENTHAL
There’s a thing that happens when you look at certain paintings by the young portrait artist Jordan Casteel. You take note of her subject, usually a black man. You look again, closer this time, and only on second glance do you recognize that his skin tone doesn’t actually resemble skin at all, but is instead blue, or green, or pink, or orange, or chalky white. You may question why you didn’t notice at first. You may marvel at Casteel’s clever palette, her ability to rationalize figure against ground, to hide a person the color of, say, the Hulk, in plain sight. If you’re thinking the way she hopes you’re thinking, you may wonder why you were so quick to clock his race. Maybe you wonder what other judgments you jumped to in the process.
“Which I love!” Casteel says when I describe it as a sort of magic-eye trick. “That was very intentional.” The artist, 29, is lanky and long-limbed, with a boyish haircut and the easy, funky style—’80s jeans, white Nikes, colorful socks, oversize glasses—of a very cool fifth grader. We’re sitting side by side on a sofa on the lower level of the Casey Kaplan gallery, where this fall Casteel mounted a much buzzed-about exhibition of paintings, “Nights in Harlem.” “I was interested in the fact that people were going, ‘Oh, you’re painting black men.’ And then they would be like: ‘Oh, actually, he’s green.’ I loved witnessing the externalization of that internal process.”
She goes on: “I consider myself a painter in the most technical way. I spend probably the majority of my time thinking about the nuance of color and composition, and that’s usually not the conversation.”
Whatever conversation has been happening around Casteel’s work, it’s lately been building to a fever pitch. Some of the chatter concerns her biography: Casteel was born and raised in Denver and is the daughter of a social justice activist mom, herself the daughter of civil rights hero Whitney Moore Young, Jr. He passed away long before his granddaughter was born, but Casteel grew up with a keen sense of “the legacy that my bloodline held.” (Appended to her email signature is a quote from her grandfather: “I am not anxious to be the loudest voice or the most popular. But I would like to think that at a crucial moment, I was an effective voice of the voiceless, an effective hope of the hopeless.”)
“My mom,” she continues, “has been really clear from the beginning that as powerful as that legacy is, the most important part is doing the work for oneself. There’s a difference between symbols and substance.” That gulf informs her paintings, too. Casteel had virtually no formal fine arts training when she applied and was accepted to Yale’s MFA program. She arrived with a style all her own—a loose, exaggerated manner of rendering the human figure that she claims is the only arrow in her artistic quiver (“I don’t know how to do anything else; I tried; it was a disaster”)—and the unfashionable desire, in an age of conceptual art, to pursue figurative painting. “Everybody was like, ‘Good luck!’ ” she remembers, guffawing. “When you have an art history that’s so saturated with figuration, what do you have that’s any different than anybody else? Great: You see somebody. We’re all seeing somebody. What is it that’s different that you offer?”
Except, of course, that Western art—particularly portraiture—has always privileged whiteness. Perhaps not coincidentally, as this country has reckoned in recent years with the dire need for broader representation in all facets of the culture, there’s been a simultaneous renaissance in representational art. “Why is portraiture returning now?” the writer Dushko Petrovich asked recently in T magazine. “For one, there is an institutional urgency to speak to a more diverse audience with painting that depicts the black community, the Asian-American experience, the Latino face, to attract the various people who had been excluded from the museum by remaking the history of figurative painting, this time with color.” Consider Lynette Yiadom Boakye’s classical oil paintings of fictional black figures (“suggestions of people,” she’s called them), or Toyin Ojih Odutola’s intricate, narrative drawings of an imaginary clan of West African aristocrats, unburdened by the legacy of slavery. Consider the recent fervor over Kehinde Wiley and Amy Sherald’s just-unveiled presidential portraits of Barack and Michelle Obama—“I saw history being made,” Casteel says. “Portraits suddenly became important in the context of politics”—or the popularity of Kerry James Marshall’s 2016 traveling retrospective “Mastry,” which traced his long quest to reinsert black faces into the Western art historical canon.
If Marshall’s work considers the erasures of history, Casteel’s is very much set in the present tense (though her paintings are less a literal transcription of real life than they may seem: “I like to think of them as being able to wobble in and out of these flat and hyperrealistic spaces”). The artist found her focus in 2013, while on a summer landscape painting fellowship in Gloucester, Massachusetts, after news broke that a Florida jury had acquitted George Zimmerman, the neighborhood watchman who a year earlier had shot and killed 17-year-old Trayvon Martin in cold blood. Casteel, who grew up with two brothers (one her twin), turned her attention to painting the black men in her life, in part as a means of showcasing individuality and three-dimensionality where the culture insisted on seeing only racist stereotypes. She centered her nascent art practice on “telling stories of people who are often unseen, making someone slow down and engage with them.” One early series—Brothers—focused on pairs and trios of figures in relation to one another. Another—Visible Man—consisted of nudes, artfully posed to hide their genitalia, stripped of any garments that might politicize their identities. Casteel’s models—their expressions coy, defiant, tender—return the viewer’s stare, complicating the artist’s deliberate inversion of the standard paradigm: male gaze, female subject. Though not literally exposed, they appear surrounded by personal ephemera (a disco ball; a forlorn stuffed elephant), revealing some incontrovertibly private side of themselves.
In 2015, Casteel moved from Ridgewood, Queens, to Harlem for a residency at the Studio Museum. The neighborhood, “the only place [in New York] I’ve ever felt at ease,” has given her a community in which to root her art. In the past few years, she’s painted men she’s met while strolling the streets, many of them local characters or street-stall vendors. She’ll introduce herself, take their photos, then work from those images in her studio to compose larger-than-life portraits set against fantastically textured streetscapes.
“To take somebody else’s image, you feel you become the holder of a piece of them,” she observes. The portraits, more than just a snapshot of a moment, enshrine what Casteel has referred to as “two-sided generosity,” the relationship that is forged in the making of the art, “something bigger than just the painting itself.” (That impulse to build community, she offers, may derive in part from her struggle with lupus, a chronic autoimmune disease that makes her, by necessity, both something of a homebody and someone who “really desires authenticity, because everything else feels so fleeting.”) In a short documentary made by Art 21 about Casteel’s work, we can see the other side of that equation. At an opening, some of her subjects confront their likeness on the gallery walls. “I feel like a superstar,” declares a man named Quentin, depicted by Casteel in a hoodie emblazoned with a picture of Biggie Smalls. “I can’t stop blushing.”
She’s gained a reputation around Harlem. “They call me ‘Painter,’ and they pass me around to one another,” she says. “There’s this sense of respect that has been built, because I’m no longer just a person who appeared one day. I’m a person who is moving through the neighborhood with a certain amount of intention and purpose.” In the film, Casteel talks to a group visiting her studio. “There have been some criticisms of, I only paint men. Every time people are like, ‘When are you going to paint women?’ I’m like, ‘I don’t know if I feel absence, because I’m very much a part of this work, and it’s translated through my experience.’ ”
To paraphrase Oscar Wilde: Every portrait is a self-portrait. It does bear mentioning, though, that Casteel actually is now painting women. Upstairs at the gallery, in a back room, hangs a new canvas, an image of three figures, two younger men, one older woman, leaning against a kitchen counter. They are the proprietors of Benyam, an Ethiopian restaurant near the high-ceilinged upper Harlem apartment Casteel recently purchased.
“I’m in a place where the expansiveness of the work is most important to me,” she says, “thinking about its ability to evolve organically, and not be stagnant in what it has to represent.” She’s having a moment, the artist acknowledges, but what she wants is staying power, a long career that transcends any passing trend for or against portraiture. “I think the challenge for many African Americans is that there’s a pigeonholing. This is black art. This is how we understand it. This is the way we talk about it. There’s not a lot of room for nuance outside of that. I want to be part of something bigger than just a moment. It’s about breaking more intrinsic systems to make room for people to flow in after.”
Her peak, she hopes, remains far in the future. I bring up Alex Katz, a painter who bucked the postwar fashion for abstract expressionism in favor of figuration, and who at 90 is still painting, who likes to say that he’s better at it now than ever before. “Ninety!” Casteel exclaims, with another of her big laughs. “Talk to me when I’m 90. I hope I’m like, Actually, I’m the shit now! Like, Nailed it! That’s the dream. To be able to be painting at 90, and feel like, Now I have done the thing that I’ve lived my life trying to understand.”